This video discussed some moral dilemmas and the various ethical standpoints that one might take within them. I expected to have an easy, utilitarian answer to most of these dilemmas, but I was shocked to find that these situations were quite difficult to decipher.
Most memorably, the professor discussed a situation in which a man could be killed to save five children. The choice was between pulling a lever to divert a railcar, and pushing the man over a bridge to stop its motion. At first, I was sure that pulling the lever to save the children was worth it, but I was more hesitant to push the man over the bridge. Although I would have been killing him either way, the physical act of murder is much harder to swallow than a distanced act. This is a "foreseen but intended" and "intended" dilemma, where a distanced killing seems more tolerable than the other--despite the fact that somebody still dies.
Another, similar situation was the one in which a doctor discussed killing "you" to donate "your" organs to five other people. The professor explained that this was the exact same situation as the railcar and the children, which shocked me: I had not seen the connection until he explained it, and I was ready to say that the potential donor should go ahead and sacrifice his life. However, I changed my mind as soon as the first-person perspective was introduced. This shows that I am probably too selfish to sacrifice my life, and it demonstrates the power of egocentrism as compared to self-sacrifice.
Biblical Ethics Blog Ambrose Ho
Thursday, March 10, 2016
Wednesday, February 3, 2016
Daily Blog Post #12
After about a month of writing daily blogs, I found that it was not as bad as I thought it would be. Although I thought that I would be tired of the blogging after a month, it turned out that I actually enjoyed putting down my experiences every day. I wish that I had more exciting things to blog about, but nothing really eventful has happened in my life or in the world at large. I hope that I can keep consistent with my uploading, because it honestly is a good way of expression.
Tuesday, February 2, 2016
Daily Blog #11
Recently, we have been reading some Shakespearean literature in Lit class. This got me thinking: even though Christian tradition mandates that its practitioners get rid of all superstition and folklore, there are lots of occult references in Shakespeare.
William Shakespeare himself was a professed Christian, also shown in many of his plays and poems, but he also displayed an extensive knowledge of things that are usually considered non-Christian. Although this may be construed as simply a cultural thing, similar to how I know many Chinese stories, Shakespeare evidently has a deeper understanding of these myths and legends than I do. Foremost among these are the witches in Macbeth and Puck from Midsummer's Night Dream. Maybe writing these characters into his plays caused him a moral dilemma, but he conformed to add them in for entertainment value.
Friday, January 29, 2016
Daily Blog Post #10
Today was the Teacher Student All Star game, and I was extremely excited to participate. However, my anticipation was tempered by the flawed voting, which actually led to some people feeling very uncomfortable.
Some people do not vote seriously for the All Star game, choosing students who do not play basketball or even sports at all to participate. These people actually won the voting, leading to a lot of debate on whether they wanted to play or not. Student Council even threatened to exclude the sophomores from the game because of it. In the end, the correct people were voted in, but the bad voting still overshadowed my mood a little.
Some people do not vote seriously for the All Star game, choosing students who do not play basketball or even sports at all to participate. These people actually won the voting, leading to a lot of debate on whether they wanted to play or not. Student Council even threatened to exclude the sophomores from the game because of it. In the end, the correct people were voted in, but the bad voting still overshadowed my mood a little.
Thursday, January 28, 2016
Daily Blog Post #9
Today, we finally made our presentation for the social experiment. Although not all of our tests got the desired results, we were able to create a cohesive presentation out of what we did have. Our main points were that we were unable to get the desired results from our tests, but we also went over what we could have done better.
In essence, our tests were unsuccessful because not enough people took them seriously. This led to almost nobody cheating in the control group, because they did not want the candy enough to actually finish the test and cheat while doing it. This means that the Ten Commandments question essentially had no effect, as the scores stayed low anyway. If we were to redesign the experiment, we might consider including money as the prize instead of candy, as this might push the students to work harder.
In essence, our tests were unsuccessful because not enough people took them seriously. This led to almost nobody cheating in the control group, because they did not want the candy enough to actually finish the test and cheat while doing it. This means that the Ten Commandments question essentially had no effect, as the scores stayed low anyway. If we were to redesign the experiment, we might consider including money as the prize instead of candy, as this might push the students to work harder.
Wednesday, January 27, 2016
Daily Blog Post #8
Like many students in this school, I have tutors on weekdays and weekends. Today, I faced a moral dilemma about facing one of my lessons, and I think I resolved it in the best way possible (for once.)
Since we have late training on Wednesdays, we only got out of school at around 6:30 pm. I had a lesson at 7:30, and the trip home takes about forty-five minutes. But I was tired and dehydrated, and I couldn't face another hour and a half of school that night. I thought about calling my teacher and cancelling for the night, and going off to City One for dinner with my friends. In the end, though, I decided not to, and I got on the bus and arrived at home barely in time. Even though it is only a small moral victory, I feel like I accomplished something by doing the right thing in this situation.
Tuesday, January 26, 2016
Daily Blog #7
Today, I was meant to collect the results for our social experiments, and complete the presentation in class. However, my group ran into a few hitches on the way, and this caused us to be unable to complete the presentation in time.
Since our experiment consists of three parts, we had to collect the tests from our three rounds of participants. However, I was surprised to find that the take-home tests we administered were very poorly done. We had assumed that everybody would cheat on those, given that they could do so easily. However, it seemed that nobody really cared enough to cheat. They achieved slightly higher scores than the other control group, but there was no difference otherwise. It seems like our promised prize of candy wasn't good enough; perhaps we should have used money as an incentive instead.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)