Thursday, March 10, 2016

Biola University video blog

This video discussed some moral dilemmas and the various ethical standpoints that one might take within them. I expected to have an easy, utilitarian answer to most of these dilemmas, but I was shocked to find that these situations were quite difficult to decipher.

Most memorably, the professor discussed a situation in which a man could be killed to save  five children. The choice was between pulling a lever to divert a railcar, and pushing the man over a bridge to stop its motion. At first, I was sure that pulling the lever to save the children was worth it, but I was more hesitant to push the man over the bridge. Although I would have been killing him either way, the physical act of murder is much harder to swallow than a distanced act. This is a "foreseen but intended" and "intended" dilemma, where a distanced killing seems more tolerable than the other--despite the fact that somebody still dies.

Another, similar situation was the one in which a doctor discussed killing "you" to donate "your" organs to five other people. The professor explained that this was the exact same situation as the railcar and the children, which shocked me: I had not seen the connection until he explained it, and I was ready to say that the potential donor should go ahead and sacrifice his life. However, I changed my mind as soon as the first-person perspective was introduced. This shows that I am probably too selfish to sacrifice my life, and it demonstrates the power of egocentrism as compared to self-sacrifice.