This video discussed some moral dilemmas and the various ethical standpoints that one might take within them. I expected to have an easy, utilitarian answer to most of these dilemmas, but I was shocked to find that these situations were quite difficult to decipher.
Most memorably, the professor discussed a situation in which a man could be killed to save five children. The choice was between pulling a lever to divert a railcar, and pushing the man over a bridge to stop its motion. At first, I was sure that pulling the lever to save the children was worth it, but I was more hesitant to push the man over the bridge. Although I would have been killing him either way, the physical act of murder is much harder to swallow than a distanced act. This is a "foreseen but intended" and "intended" dilemma, where a distanced killing seems more tolerable than the other--despite the fact that somebody still dies.
Another, similar situation was the one in which a doctor discussed killing "you" to donate "your" organs to five other people. The professor explained that this was the exact same situation as the railcar and the children, which shocked me: I had not seen the connection until he explained it, and I was ready to say that the potential donor should go ahead and sacrifice his life. However, I changed my mind as soon as the first-person perspective was introduced. This shows that I am probably too selfish to sacrifice my life, and it demonstrates the power of egocentrism as compared to self-sacrifice.
Thursday, March 10, 2016
Wednesday, February 3, 2016
Daily Blog Post #12
After about a month of writing daily blogs, I found that it was not as bad as I thought it would be. Although I thought that I would be tired of the blogging after a month, it turned out that I actually enjoyed putting down my experiences every day. I wish that I had more exciting things to blog about, but nothing really eventful has happened in my life or in the world at large. I hope that I can keep consistent with my uploading, because it honestly is a good way of expression.
Tuesday, February 2, 2016
Daily Blog #11
Recently, we have been reading some Shakespearean literature in Lit class. This got me thinking: even though Christian tradition mandates that its practitioners get rid of all superstition and folklore, there are lots of occult references in Shakespeare.
William Shakespeare himself was a professed Christian, also shown in many of his plays and poems, but he also displayed an extensive knowledge of things that are usually considered non-Christian. Although this may be construed as simply a cultural thing, similar to how I know many Chinese stories, Shakespeare evidently has a deeper understanding of these myths and legends than I do. Foremost among these are the witches in Macbeth and Puck from Midsummer's Night Dream. Maybe writing these characters into his plays caused him a moral dilemma, but he conformed to add them in for entertainment value.
Friday, January 29, 2016
Daily Blog Post #10
Today was the Teacher Student All Star game, and I was extremely excited to participate. However, my anticipation was tempered by the flawed voting, which actually led to some people feeling very uncomfortable.
Some people do not vote seriously for the All Star game, choosing students who do not play basketball or even sports at all to participate. These people actually won the voting, leading to a lot of debate on whether they wanted to play or not. Student Council even threatened to exclude the sophomores from the game because of it. In the end, the correct people were voted in, but the bad voting still overshadowed my mood a little.
Some people do not vote seriously for the All Star game, choosing students who do not play basketball or even sports at all to participate. These people actually won the voting, leading to a lot of debate on whether they wanted to play or not. Student Council even threatened to exclude the sophomores from the game because of it. In the end, the correct people were voted in, but the bad voting still overshadowed my mood a little.
Thursday, January 28, 2016
Daily Blog Post #9
Today, we finally made our presentation for the social experiment. Although not all of our tests got the desired results, we were able to create a cohesive presentation out of what we did have. Our main points were that we were unable to get the desired results from our tests, but we also went over what we could have done better.
In essence, our tests were unsuccessful because not enough people took them seriously. This led to almost nobody cheating in the control group, because they did not want the candy enough to actually finish the test and cheat while doing it. This means that the Ten Commandments question essentially had no effect, as the scores stayed low anyway. If we were to redesign the experiment, we might consider including money as the prize instead of candy, as this might push the students to work harder.
In essence, our tests were unsuccessful because not enough people took them seriously. This led to almost nobody cheating in the control group, because they did not want the candy enough to actually finish the test and cheat while doing it. This means that the Ten Commandments question essentially had no effect, as the scores stayed low anyway. If we were to redesign the experiment, we might consider including money as the prize instead of candy, as this might push the students to work harder.
Wednesday, January 27, 2016
Daily Blog Post #8
Like many students in this school, I have tutors on weekdays and weekends. Today, I faced a moral dilemma about facing one of my lessons, and I think I resolved it in the best way possible (for once.)
Since we have late training on Wednesdays, we only got out of school at around 6:30 pm. I had a lesson at 7:30, and the trip home takes about forty-five minutes. But I was tired and dehydrated, and I couldn't face another hour and a half of school that night. I thought about calling my teacher and cancelling for the night, and going off to City One for dinner with my friends. In the end, though, I decided not to, and I got on the bus and arrived at home barely in time. Even though it is only a small moral victory, I feel like I accomplished something by doing the right thing in this situation.
Tuesday, January 26, 2016
Daily Blog #7
Today, I was meant to collect the results for our social experiments, and complete the presentation in class. However, my group ran into a few hitches on the way, and this caused us to be unable to complete the presentation in time.
Since our experiment consists of three parts, we had to collect the tests from our three rounds of participants. However, I was surprised to find that the take-home tests we administered were very poorly done. We had assumed that everybody would cheat on those, given that they could do so easily. However, it seemed that nobody really cared enough to cheat. They achieved slightly higher scores than the other control group, but there was no difference otherwise. It seems like our promised prize of candy wasn't good enough; perhaps we should have used money as an incentive instead.
Monday, January 25, 2016
Daily Blog Post #6
Today is a Monday, and I really dislike them for a very good reason. It seems way more difficult to get out of bed than on any other day, especially when it is cold. It took my sister and I an hour to get out of the front door, and it was lucky that we had a study hall, or else we would have been late for sure.
I have no idea why I find it so difficult to wake up in those positions. Even though I have had plenty of sleep the night before, I still cannot seem to drag myself out of bed. I know it is not a physical problem, but a mental one. I am extremely grateful for the education that I have, and I need to demonstrate it in my daily life.
I have no idea why I find it so difficult to wake up in those positions. Even though I have had plenty of sleep the night before, I still cannot seem to drag myself out of bed. I know it is not a physical problem, but a mental one. I am extremely grateful for the education that I have, and I need to demonstrate it in my daily life.
Daily Blog Post #5
Today, I began to sign up for NHS. I don't have a great understanding of what NHS is, but one of the questions asked me how I felt about my character. This got me thinking: what kind of person do I think I am?
I am definitely not perfect, but I do have what is probably a defining characteristic. When given a task, I always carry it out to the best of my ability. This speaks to my persistence and my strength of character, because I am able to give my all regardless of the situation. However, I also tend to be overly critical of other people when I think that they are not giving all that they can. I usually like being a leader, but this means that I am in a position to criticize a lot. I can be quite harsh with my words, which is something I definitely need to work on.
Thursday, January 21, 2016
Daily Journal #4
Today is one of the most exciting days of my life, ever. I played in my first overtime basketball game, and Aidan Leung hit a game winner at the buzzer to clinch a playoff spot. I am still in a daze about it, because it seemed so unlikely that we would win. But I also noticed a negative element in how I represented ICS today.
It is generally accepted by the coaches, the players, and even the spectators that the league referees are absolutely terrible. This game, we picked up eight team fouls in the first quarter, while the other team had exactly none. I made a few comments to the referees and said a few things when the whistle blew against us, and this definitely was not the right thing to do. I knew that there was a great chance that I might get a technical foul, since I tend to be a bit rude in the heat of the game. This is definitely something I need to work on, as the referees are just doing their job, and I should not blame them for the tough calls they must make.
It is generally accepted by the coaches, the players, and even the spectators that the league referees are absolutely terrible. This game, we picked up eight team fouls in the first quarter, while the other team had exactly none. I made a few comments to the referees and said a few things when the whistle blew against us, and this definitely was not the right thing to do. I knew that there was a great chance that I might get a technical foul, since I tend to be a bit rude in the heat of the game. This is definitely something I need to work on, as the referees are just doing their job, and I should not blame them for the tough calls they must make.
Wednesday, January 20, 2016
Daily Journal #3
This is my third daily journal, and I want to speak a bit on the social experiments we are performing in class. I think that it is a unique concept that I would not be able to try out in any other class, so I am grateful for the opportunity.
I have always known that people cheat around me, and I may or may not have engaged in it at some point or another. I have also known that teachers are quite prescient in regards to cheating, and that they probably allow some of it to pass them by. I was not expecting an experiment that would outright test how much a person cheated. At first, I thought it was a bit strange that we would test something like that, but I now realize that it presents an opportunity to see just how honest we really are. I think that people of different social groups will definitely cheat, and the planted cheater will definitely have a huge impact, but that remains to be seen.
I have always known that people cheat around me, and I may or may not have engaged in it at some point or another. I have also known that teachers are quite prescient in regards to cheating, and that they probably allow some of it to pass them by. I was not expecting an experiment that would outright test how much a person cheated. At first, I thought it was a bit strange that we would test something like that, but I now realize that it presents an opportunity to see just how honest we really are. I think that people of different social groups will definitely cheat, and the planted cheater will definitely have a huge impact, but that remains to be seen.
Tuesday, January 19, 2016
Daily Journal #2
This is my second day of daily journaling, and I was thinking about the school dress code recently. The speaker in chapel spurred my thinking, as the topic he was discussing is quite similar to the dress code issue at school.
Basically, students are not allowed to wear many items at school for fear of a detention, and this applies less to me than it does the seniors. Last year, a few seniors wore tank tops to school on their Friday free dress day (both male and female,) and this ended up in the free dress day being canceled altogether for the next few weeks. The school's ethics of modesty obviously do not match up with the students'. As for my side of things, I feel like some rules in the dress code are ridiculous, such as the tank top rule. Boys play basketball and work out in tank tops, and girls usually have the good sense not to wear ones that are revealing, so there really should be no issue--especially if it is on a free dress day. Some rules are necessary, though: the ones regulating skirt length and makeup are quite pragmatic and help the school's image.
Basically, students are not allowed to wear many items at school for fear of a detention, and this applies less to me than it does the seniors. Last year, a few seniors wore tank tops to school on their Friday free dress day (both male and female,) and this ended up in the free dress day being canceled altogether for the next few weeks. The school's ethics of modesty obviously do not match up with the students'. As for my side of things, I feel like some rules in the dress code are ridiculous, such as the tank top rule. Boys play basketball and work out in tank tops, and girls usually have the good sense not to wear ones that are revealing, so there really should be no issue--especially if it is on a free dress day. Some rules are necessary, though: the ones regulating skirt length and makeup are quite pragmatic and help the school's image.
Monday, January 18, 2016
Daily Journal #1
Today is the first day of our daily blogging, and I think that it is going to be a big challenge for me. In general, I am quite bad at remembering assignments, even if they are meant to be completed daily. I also lack the responsibility to keep up with something like this. I will do my best, though, and see where it goes from there.
A moral dilemma I faced today was one of selfishness. Like many students do, I ordered lunch in the morning before school, and went downstairs to get it after it was delivered. The only problem was that I was meant to go and get somebody else's as well. They weren't delivered by the same person, and this meant I had to wait for the delivery person to go back to the store. I didn't have a jacket and it was cold that day, so I really didn't want to wait. Even though I ended up getting the food for my friend anyway, I felt really bad about my attitude. I can't believe that I wasn't willing to wait for just a few minutes, just so I could go upstairs and eat my lunch first. This was very selfish of me and it is probably just a small example of how self-centered I can be.
A moral dilemma I faced today was one of selfishness. Like many students do, I ordered lunch in the morning before school, and went downstairs to get it after it was delivered. The only problem was that I was meant to go and get somebody else's as well. They weren't delivered by the same person, and this meant I had to wait for the delivery person to go back to the store. I didn't have a jacket and it was cold that day, so I really didn't want to wait. Even though I ended up getting the food for my friend anyway, I felt really bad about my attitude. I can't believe that I wasn't willing to wait for just a few minutes, just so I could go upstairs and eat my lunch first. This was very selfish of me and it is probably just a small example of how self-centered I can be.
Wednesday, January 13, 2016
Journal #4: Buggy Moral Code
What was surprising to you/did you learn from the video? Does cheating matter?
After watching the video, I found that cheating is a lot more common that I thought. I assumed that there were more honest people than cheaters, but that does not seem to be the case. In truth, it seems that cheating is basically the norm, but only because people can actually get away with it. I cheat sometimes as well, but I have found that I don't really have a fudge factor: I always feel bad about cheating, regardless of the time or how much I cheat.
Cheating really does matter, because it is the basis of most sins. When corporations collapse and nations fall, it is because somebody thought that it was acceptable to cheat for the sake of their goals. Even if it is impossible to prevent cheating, it should be foremost among somebody's values to avoid cheating.
After watching the video, I found that cheating is a lot more common that I thought. I assumed that there were more honest people than cheaters, but that does not seem to be the case. In truth, it seems that cheating is basically the norm, but only because people can actually get away with it. I cheat sometimes as well, but I have found that I don't really have a fudge factor: I always feel bad about cheating, regardless of the time or how much I cheat.
Cheating really does matter, because it is the basis of most sins. When corporations collapse and nations fall, it is because somebody thought that it was acceptable to cheat for the sake of their goals. Even if it is impossible to prevent cheating, it should be foremost among somebody's values to avoid cheating.
Monday, January 11, 2016
Journal #4, 11 Jan 2016
Today, I underwent a moral dilemma that I experience regularly. When confronted with the option to jaywalk, I went ahead and saved myself some time, walking across the street before the crossing light had turned green. Doing this is almost second nature for me at this point, because I grew up in Hong Kong and my parents basically taught me jaywalking as a way of life. Everybody is in a hurry here, trying to get places more quickly, and we are always impatient to reach our destination faster.
However, I have realized that jaywalking is not ethically right. I don't do it around policemen, because I know that I might get caught and cautioned. Technically, it is breaking the law, and it shows a complete contempt for the official statutes of Hong Kong. Even though I always check to make sure I am safe before crossing a road (safety being the purpose of the no-jaywalking rule), I am still disobeying the law. As such, I am going to try to ease jaywalking out of my bad habits. It's not going to happen overnight, so I really need to commit to it to find results.
However, I have realized that jaywalking is not ethically right. I don't do it around policemen, because I know that I might get caught and cautioned. Technically, it is breaking the law, and it shows a complete contempt for the official statutes of Hong Kong. Even though I always check to make sure I am safe before crossing a road (safety being the purpose of the no-jaywalking rule), I am still disobeying the law. As such, I am going to try to ease jaywalking out of my bad habits. It's not going to happen overnight, so I really need to commit to it to find results.
Thursday, January 7, 2016
Journal #3
Find a current news story that gives an example where
an ethic is in conflict with a moral/morality.
This is not exactly a current news story, but I feel that it has great relevance in our lives today. During the Umbrella Revolution of last year, there was a group of students who felt that universal suffrage was necessary in Hong Kong. However, their methods of convincing the public were unorthodox and disruptive. In purported "peaceful situations," these students, and many others, barricaded Hong Kong's roads and public areas. They also stormed the Hong Kong government buildings, destroying property without heed. However, this was all in the name of suffrage.
According to the students' morals, there should have been universal suffrage, and they undertook this venture to achieve this. However, this is incorrect ethically, because they ruined many lives with their reckless actions. Stores in Mong Kok and Admiralty were shut down because of their actions, and their usage of violence in the government building raid shows that they were not above that. While their actions were purportedly for peace, they showed it in an unethical way.
Morally, their actions contradicted their words. Occupy Central was meant to be a peaceful movement, as nobody was meant to harm anybody else. However, this turned out not to be the case, as many attacked police officers, and this led to the usage of nonlethal weaponry against the protesters. Although the police were blamed for the incident, there was definitely no choice in the matter, as the protesters' actions showed a complete lack of morals.
Tuesday, January 5, 2016
Journal #2
Kentucky Clerk: Kim Davis
Even though the US Supreme Court ruled in favor of same-sex marriage, Kentucky county clerk Kim Davis disagreed with their ruling. What do you think is the right thing to do in this situation, ethically and morally?
Ethically, the right thing to do would to be depose Davis from her standing as county clerk. By refusing same-sex marriage, she is violating US law. Even if she claims that she acts on a religious standing, she has not been a paragon herself: she has been married four separate times, and her denial of others' rights is an un-Christian act in itself. The Declaration of Independence and the Bible both give man the rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, yet the course of justice is being obstructed by a single person's refusal to comply with state law. If she does not want to change with the times, she can get out of office.
Morally, Davis seems to conform to an ultra-conservative version of Christianity. There is nothing wrong with that, as she is free to believe in whatever she wants, and freedom of speech means that she even has the right to express these beliefs. Though the dissenters against same-sex marriage used to outnumber its supporters, the pro-gay party is now in the vast majority, and many are Christians who strongly profess their beliefs. As such, Davis now shares a belief with many other Christians, and they should use the same Bible: one that states that God loves everybody without restraint. God makes no differentiation between loving gays or straight people, so why should Davis refuse their love? By doing so, she is putting herself above God, as judge and jury for these loving couples.
Even though the US Supreme Court ruled in favor of same-sex marriage, Kentucky county clerk Kim Davis disagreed with their ruling. What do you think is the right thing to do in this situation, ethically and morally?
Ethically, the right thing to do would to be depose Davis from her standing as county clerk. By refusing same-sex marriage, she is violating US law. Even if she claims that she acts on a religious standing, she has not been a paragon herself: she has been married four separate times, and her denial of others' rights is an un-Christian act in itself. The Declaration of Independence and the Bible both give man the rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, yet the course of justice is being obstructed by a single person's refusal to comply with state law. If she does not want to change with the times, she can get out of office.
Morally, Davis seems to conform to an ultra-conservative version of Christianity. There is nothing wrong with that, as she is free to believe in whatever she wants, and freedom of speech means that she even has the right to express these beliefs. Though the dissenters against same-sex marriage used to outnumber its supporters, the pro-gay party is now in the vast majority, and many are Christians who strongly profess their beliefs. As such, Davis now shares a belief with many other Christians, and they should use the same Bible: one that states that God loves everybody without restraint. God makes no differentiation between loving gays or straight people, so why should Davis refuse their love? By doing so, she is putting herself above God, as judge and jury for these loving couples.
Monday, January 4, 2016
Journal #1
Where do you get your moral ethic?
I acquired my moral ethic from my parents and my teachers over the years. When I was younger, my parents instilled a sense of right and wrong into me. From a young age, I was able to differentiate between what was necessary and what wasn't. I knew my limits as a human and what could or could not be done--my ethical compass, if you will. However, I did not have a set of morals until I reached kindergarten. There, my teachers outlined a set of rules that I had to follow. Most of them dealt with treating others in a suitable manner, sharing, and the rest of the asinine kindergarten-level rules that prevent total anarchy. However, I have remembered them to this day, and I still try to follow them as much as possible.
Other places I get my my morality are my experiences, my friends, and the internet. My friends are a constant sense of right in my life because I like to spend time with people who have good morals. Also, I can learn what to do from my experiences, because I understand what is wrong and what is right from what I have done in the past. Finally, the Internet may be full of potentially dangerous sites, but I can still learn some things from it.
I acquired my moral ethic from my parents and my teachers over the years. When I was younger, my parents instilled a sense of right and wrong into me. From a young age, I was able to differentiate between what was necessary and what wasn't. I knew my limits as a human and what could or could not be done--my ethical compass, if you will. However, I did not have a set of morals until I reached kindergarten. There, my teachers outlined a set of rules that I had to follow. Most of them dealt with treating others in a suitable manner, sharing, and the rest of the asinine kindergarten-level rules that prevent total anarchy. However, I have remembered them to this day, and I still try to follow them as much as possible.
Other places I get my my morality are my experiences, my friends, and the internet. My friends are a constant sense of right in my life because I like to spend time with people who have good morals. Also, I can learn what to do from my experiences, because I understand what is wrong and what is right from what I have done in the past. Finally, the Internet may be full of potentially dangerous sites, but I can still learn some things from it.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)