Kentucky Clerk: Kim Davis
Even though the US Supreme Court ruled in favor of same-sex marriage, Kentucky county clerk Kim Davis disagreed with their ruling. What do you think is the right thing to do in this situation, ethically and morally?
Ethically, the right thing to do would to be depose Davis from her standing as county clerk. By refusing same-sex marriage, she is violating US law. Even if she claims that she acts on a religious standing, she has not been a paragon herself: she has been married four separate times, and her denial of others' rights is an un-Christian act in itself. The Declaration of Independence and the Bible both give man the rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, yet the course of justice is being obstructed by a single person's refusal to comply with state law. If she does not want to change with the times, she can get out of office.
Morally, Davis seems to conform to an ultra-conservative version of Christianity. There is nothing wrong with that, as she is free to believe in whatever she wants, and freedom of speech means that she even has the right to express these beliefs. Though the dissenters against same-sex marriage used to outnumber its supporters, the pro-gay party is now in the vast majority, and many are Christians who strongly profess their beliefs. As such, Davis now shares a belief with many other Christians, and they should use the same Bible: one that states that God loves everybody without restraint. God makes no differentiation between loving gays or straight people, so why should Davis refuse their love? By doing so, she is putting herself above God, as judge and jury for these loving couples.
No comments:
Post a Comment